I’ve now written three blog posts explaining why I never, ever, ever, EVER, EVER, EVER tell people how it’s done.
OK, so here’s the thing: sometimes I can be a little over-emphatic.
I may have made my feelings about the “How Do You Do That?” question sound a little more black-and-white than they actually are when I explained my ethical objections to answering it alongside my Father Christmas approach to responding. You, dear reader, have been very patient in wading through these posts, and so now I will reward your perseverance by explaining the situations in which I take a slightly less dogmatic approach to the subject, and don’t just dodge the question. These situations arise when the “how” question arrives with a slightly different intent from normal – and it usually falls into one of three categories:
1) The Business Question: “Can you teach my sales team to do that?”
This question arises when someone sees the potential value of what they just saw (or, at least, what they think they just saw) and what that might mean in the real world. If you could really know what a customer was thinking… or the maximum a client would be willing to pay for your company’s widgets next quarter… well, that would be extremely useful.
But here’s the issue: I don’t really read minds. I use a wide range of techniques to create the illusion of mind reading. There’s that saying about people who have hammers always seeing every problem as a nail. If you’re a skilled business person, it’s very easy to look at what I do and assume I’m using highly refined versions of the skills you use in business, particularly in sales and customer relations.
But the techniques that make a mind-reading show work are nothing like the skills that make a business work. In fact, the only parts of what I do that would transfer cleanly into the real world tend to be skills involving deception, subterfuge, and manipulation.
Which means:
- they just wouldn’t fly in a healthy business environment
- they would be unethical
- and most of them, placed in a business context, would almost certainly be illegal.
So no – as with almost everyone else who asks me “how”, I don’t teach businesses how to “read minds” either.
What I can, and will very happily do, is work with management, trainers and facilitators to perform at conferences, team building events and training sessions, so that they can use what I do to inspire people to ask questions, look at things differently, or even to just take a more open-minded approach to change. That is something I am more than happy to do for you. It’s ethical, it’s effective, and best of all, it makes that training session or team retreat that no-one really wanted to attend a great deal more fun than it might have otherwise been.
The other situation in which I take a different approach to the “How did you do that” question is:
2) The “Inverted Universe” Question: Wait a second, nothing makes sense any more.
This “How” question arrives feeling very different. It’s asked very earnestly, by someone who will generally follow me outside after I’ve finished to ask me it in private, once I’m off duty. It usually comes from someone who has just experienced a very intense form of the amazement, much more intense than the one that everyone else felt.
“Hang on,” they are thinking, “I just thought of a word” (or a name, a number, a date, the specifics don’t matter) ‘something I know I didn’t say out loud – and then this bloke revealed what existed only inside my head.”
And because I’ve already told them I’m not psychic, there’s a slightly unsettling conclusion that follows: If he’s not psychic… then he learned to do this.
That’s where the urgency comes from. It’s not “I’m mildly curious”: it’s a great big stomach punch of “I really need to know what just happened.”
And honestly, that intense reaction is one of the reasons I love what I do. Because underneath the jokes and the cheekiness, the experience is genuinely strange. It pokes at how confident we all are in our perception and our memory.
But it’s also sadly based on a misunderstanding.
When I made my disclaimer at the start of my show, what this person heard was: “These are the techniques that fake psychics use.” The bit they either missed or have failed to fully factor into their reasoning, was the bit where I said: “I’m a liar, I’m a cheat – I’m a complete fraud.”
So yes, they get that I’m not psychic… but they also just experienced me naming a word they only thought of. And the fact that this can be done must completely upend their understanding of physics / psychology / human interactions.
Generally, I’ll spend a moment with them, having a very gentle conversation where I remind them about the fact that I said this was all about lyin’ and cheatin’, and that the psychology involved that they’ve somehow assumed is some ninja-level NLP stuff is actually more about the psychology of deception. It’s sort of a “Hey bud, I’ve got some bad news: this Father Christmas guy – well, you see, I’m afraid me and your Mum…” conversation, but delivered gently, in a way that doesn’t make them feel stupid. Because quite frankly, the fact they can see what it would mean if mind reading were real is a sign that they are, in fact, probably one of the smarter people at the party.
3) The “enquiring student”: I want to be able to do what you do. Could you teach me please?
Now we’re into the final category – the rare one. The people who don’t just want closure; they want to learn because they are hooked. Because that was awesome. They want to be able to do it too. It’ll make them a hit at parties. It’ll make them interesting and appealing. It’ll surely, they figure, make them a totally 100% cast iron, A-grade, rock-solid, mind-messin’ babe-magnet. Or a boy-magnet. Or both!
I know that, once upon a time, I too thought that I would somehow become irresistible to women if I could do what I do. In case you’re yet to meet me, spoiler alert: I didn’t.
Those women I somehow managed to impress with my talents tended to, after spending a further 15 minutes with me, realise that I’m really rather dull. Happily I met a somewhat delusional woman in 2018 who seems to be able to overlook that fact.
But anyway, occasionally someone comes along who, for whatever reason, genuinely wants to know how they go about learning to do whatever the freakin’ heck THAT was. Again, this will be someone who follows me out and speaks to me after a performance, or seeks me out online. Someone who is willing to do more than just ask me how I do it in the moments after seeing a trick. This will be someone who is showing motivation, and a desire to seek me out to enquire about how they too can learn to do what I do.
So here’s the deal I offer people who are genuinely motivated to learn, and who understand that the whole art form is primarily based on deception and cheating. And if you see me at a booking, and you really want to learn how to do what I do, I’ll offer you the same deal I offer everyone else who asks.
I certainly won’t tell you straight away how a specific thing worked
If what you want is a neat explanation of that one thing you just saw, so you can put the lid back on the box – no. That would spoil it for you and for everyone who hasn’t seen it yet.
But I might help you learn the road in…
If you’ve seen me perform and you’re genuinely fascinated – not so you can ruin it for other people, but because you want to understand the craft and maybe learn it yourself – I’m all for that. I actually enjoy helping people who are serious.
But there are a few conditions.
The Deal – How To Get Me To Take You Seriously
Over the course of my 30-year career, there have now been five people who saw me perform and really did actually, truly, want to learn how to do what I do. Which gives you an idea of how often they appear – I entertain literally hundreds of people every week, and one will show up once every six years on average. That’s about one in every 30,000 people I entertain. (They put the chances of being struck by lightning in your lifetime as being around 1 in 10,000 to 15,000. So two to three times as likely, basically. I’m not sure what that says about me.)
I offered all five of these earnest enquirers the same deal.
Show me that this is something you are prepared to put some work into.
What I do is based in the art of deception. There is another, closely related art of deception that is very accessible, especially nowadays in the age of the internet.
That art form is magic.
The deal I offer is this:
- Learn a couple of basic tricks (there are hundreds of instructional videos on YouTube – please don’t pay for any courses initially, there are plenty of strong, easy-to-do things available online for free.)
- Put some effort in and take some risks: try them on real people.
- If they suck or you can’t get the hang of them, try others.
- Practise. Lots. None of this stuff goes well the first time.
- Get good enough at a couple of tricks so that you can fool other people.
- Then send me a video of you doing those two tricks for some people who haven’t seen you do them before.
That’s it. That’s all I ask. Show me you are motivated enough to be introduced to the secrets of my craft by teaching yourself a couple of magic tricks.
Which tricks do I recommend you try? I don’t. Remember, this is about you showing you’re willing to put the work in. That search bar up the top of your browser is your friend, friend.
If you do these things, and you send me through a video of you doing a trick for someone, you’ve moved from being a curious person at my booking to being a fellow performer who is serious about learning the methods and psychology involved in deceiving people for the purpose of entertaining them.
And once you’re a fellow performer, I’m more than happy to be a bit of a mentor if it’s of help, and do things like:
- Point you towards some of the different resources I know of
- Explain some of the core principles (the stuff that actually matters)
- Give you a steer on where to go next
(Please note: this deal applies to people who have seen me at bookings. I’m not looking to become an online mentor for people I haven’t met. I’m just offering to help people who saw me in person and became inspired.)
One more thing…
As I’ve said, I’ve made that offer five times now in the last 30 years. Would you like to take a guess at how many of those five people, those bolts of lightning, actually took things to the next stage, learned a couple of tricks and then got back to me?
None. Not one of them took me up on the offer.
I don’t know for sure why, but I can take a couple of guesses:
My first guess: learning to trick people without coming across as a total dick is hard. You’ve got to swallow your fear and look people in the eye and ask them if you can show them something. A lot of people find even just doing that difficult. You’ve also got to make it entertaining, you’ve got to make it interesting. This takes practice: you need to do a trick in front of a number of people. These are likely be tolerant people like family, friends, workmates, or maybe social media followers – provided your trick can work over video. So you need to be willing to ask them to watch you. (Apart from the social media followers, of course – those suckers have signed up for any old rubbish you post.) And most of all, you need to have the resilience to push through the pain and embarrassment of failing, and the humiliation of getting caught cheating.
So there are plenty of points in this process where people might get frustrated and give up. You’ve really got to genuinely want it. Maybe those five people weren’t as motivated as they felt there and then in the heat of the moment.
The other possibility, of course, is that some of them did learn, and once they did, they realised they didn’t need me to show them how to do this stuff after all. What I do is entirely self-taught. The information is out there. It’s just a matter of being willing to work at it.
So maybe they found their own way into reading minds, and are now having huge fun with either their great new hobby, their brilliant new side hustle, or (as it turned out in my case) their wonderfully rewarding new career.
I sincerely hope it’s the latter of the two possibilities. Doing this for others means you get to make people feel like they’re a kid all over again. It’s a wonderful job.



